Jury Focus Groups for Trial Lawyers
Find out how jurors see your case before it counts. Alex Hoffspiegel has moderated hundreds of jury focus groups for other lawyers in civil and criminal cases of all types, while representing plaintiffs in his own cases.
Traditional jury consulting and mock jury research are usually handled by experts with a psychology or sociology background. Alex is a practicing trial lawyer, so every session is built around the decisions you actually have to make: what to emphasize, what to fix, and what your case is up against.
When Lawyers Use a Focus Group
A focus group is useful at almost every stage of a case, not just on the eve of trial.
- Deciding whether to accept a case and how much to invest in it
- During discovery, to learn what jurors want to know so you can go get it
- Before depositions, to identify the issues and witnesses that matter most to jurors
- Before mediation, to see how jurors react to the strengths and weaknesses on both sides
- Before trial, to refine themes, the order of proof, and voir dire
What a Focus Group Can Tell You About Damages
Focus groups are qualitative research, not statistical studies, so the verdict number a panel arrives at is the least reliable data point a session produces.
What a focus group does show is how jurors reason about damages: which elements they accept, which they resist, and what moves them.
What a Focus Group Can Test
- Liability and apportionment of fault
- Case themes, plaintiff’s and defense
- Primacy of evidence: which facts and exhibits jurors weigh most and what they latch onto first
- Order of presentation: what jurors need to hear first for the rest of the case to make sense
- Reactions to key evidence, including video, photographs, records, and demonstratives
- Credibility and likability of the client and key witnesses
- Negative attitudes toward the client or the case
- Unanswered questions: what jurors assume happened that nobody told them, and what they need to see
- Which defense arguments stick, and why
- Word choice and framing for openings and key arguments
- Juror attitudes and profiles to inform voir dire
- Damages: which elements jurors accept, which they discount or resist, and what moves them
- Whether jurors understand and apply the jury charge and verdict form the way you expect
Civil and Criminal Cases of All Types
- Bodily injury torts, including motor vehicle and trucking, premises liability, and negligent security
- Wrongful death
- Medical and professional malpractice
- Product liability
- Business torts
- Contract and commercial disputes
- Land use and zoning
- Property damage and fire loss
- Insurance coverage and bad faith
- Employment and civil rights
- Construction disputes
- Nursing home abuse and neglect
- Human trafficking (TVPRA)
- Eminent domain and condemnation
- Family law
- Criminal defense
How It Works
Scoping call
We talk through your goals, your biggest concerns, and the issues you want tested.
Case materials
About a week out, you send your goals, your best arguments, the defense’s best arguments, and the key documents in the case.
The presentation
Alex drafts a balanced presentation of the case and exchanges revisions with you.
Recruiting
Panelists are recruited from your venue or to match its demographics, with any exclusions the case requires. Every panelist signs a confidentiality agreement.
The session
An approximately three-hour session, held on Zoom or in person in metro Atlanta. You observe and can message Alex privately to steer the discussion.
The report
Within one week, you receive a written report analyzing the results, along with the session recording.
Focus Group Formats
Narrative
Alex presents a statement of the case, covering a neutral summary, the plaintiff’s claims, and the defenses, then draws out panelists’ attitudes, leanings, and unanswered questions. Most engagements use this format.
Adversarial
Attorneys present each side in a “clopening” presentation. This format works best once the evidence is developed and the case is in final trial preparation.
Multiple panels
The same case presented to more than one panel, with matched demographics and no overlap in panelists.
Location and Fee Arrangements
Virtual or in person
Sessions are held virtually on Zoom for cases anywhere in the country. In the metro Atlanta area, Alex also conducts focus groups in person.
Flat fee or contingency
Focus groups are available on a flat-fee basis. Contingency arrangements are available in select cases and are evaluated case by case; not every case qualifies.
The Right Panel
Panels are recruited either from residents of the venue where the case is pending or nationally to match the venue’s demographics.
Recruiting can be tailored to demographic, educational, occupational, and political targets, and can exclude anyone connected to the parties, the defendant’s industry, or any other group the case calls for. When a case is tested more than once, each session uses entirely new panelists.
What You Receive
- The case presentation, drafted with you before the session
- Polls, including an opening attitudes poll and polls on issues such as apportionment and primacy of evidence
- Panelists’ private written answers
- A written report analyzing the results, with verbatim panelist comments
- The session recording and chat log
- Signed panelist confidentiality agreements
About Alex Hoffspiegel
Alex is a practicing trial lawyer and partner at Hoffspiegel Law in Atlanta, where he represents plaintiffs in his own cases. Over the last 15+ years he has moderated hundreds of jury focus groups for other lawyers, and he conducts approximately fifty a year in civil and criminal cases of all types.
- Regular CLE speaker on jury focus groups for plaintiff’s lawyers
- Former instructor, Keenan Trial Institute
- Champion member, Georgia Trial Lawyers Association, and member of GTLA’s LEAD class
- J.D., cum laude, Georgia State University College of Law
Frequently Asked Questions
How is this different from hiring a jury consultant?
Traditional jury consultants usually come from a psychology or sociology background. Alex is a practicing trial lawyer who tries his own cases, so the presentation, the questions, and the report are designed around the practical decisions a trial lawyer has to make.
Is a focus group the same as a mock trial?
They overlap. A mock trial usually means a full adversarial presentation to a mock jury that deliberates to a verdict. A focus group is broader jury research: the presentation can be a neutral narrative, an adversarial argument from each side, or something in between, and the goal is to understand how jurors reason, not just what they decide. The adversarial format works much like a mock trial.
When is the best time to do a focus group?
Earlier than most lawyers think. A focus group can help you decide whether to accept a case, guide discovery, prepare for depositions and mediation, and refine your trial presentation.
What kinds of cases do you focus group?
Civil and criminal cases of all types, including bodily injury and wrongful death, business torts, commercial disputes, land use, property damage, and criminal defense.
Does my case need to be in Georgia?
No. Virtual sessions on Zoom work for cases anywhere, and panels can be recruited for venues across the country. In-person sessions are available in the metro Atlanta area.
How are focus groups priced?
On a flat-fee basis. Contingency arrangements are available in select cases and are evaluated case by case.
Do I attend the session?
Yes. Hiring attorneys observe the session and can message Alex privately to redirect the discussion. In an adversarial focus group, the attorneys present each side.
Is the session confidential?
Yes. Every panelist signs a confidentiality agreement before the session, and you receive the signed agreements with the report.
What do I need to provide?
Your goals, the issues you want covered, your biggest concerns, your best arguments, the defense’s best arguments, and the key documents in the case, such as the complaint, police report, expert reports and affidavits, depositions, demand letters, mediation statements, the pretrial order, and any orders with findings of fact.
Check Availability
Tell us about your case and the timing you have in mind, or call (404) 760-8600.